Cedar siding typically costs $8-17 per square foot installed in the New York area, making it more expensive upfront than vinyl or fiber cement. However, cedar delivers an 80-95% return on investment—one of the highest ROI rates for home improvements.
The initial cost reflects cedar’s superior insulation properties, natural beauty, and longevity when properly maintained. While vinyl might cost less initially, cedar adds more value to your home and provides better energy efficiency. Many Montauk homeowners find the investment worthwhile for the authentic wood appearance and increased resale value.